Before we begin analyzing the libertarian lessons
of South Park, we must first define what a libertarian is. Conservatives
believe that libertarians are pot-smoking hippies. Liberals believe that
libertarians are either anarchists or corporate tycoons who only care about
money. Neither one of these definitions is true. We can define libertarianism
with the following two definitions:
1. A libertarian is someone who opposes the
initiation of force to achieve political or social goals. (This is the pledge
you take when you become a member of the Libertarian Party.)
2. A libertarian is fiscally responsible and
socially tolerant. Some say that libertarians are half-Democrat and
half-Republican.
You may notice that I’m spelling libertarian with
a miniscule “l”. I have to make a distinction between libertarians and
Libertarians. A Libertarian is a member of the Libertarian Party. A libertarian
is someone who believes in libertarianism, but not necessarily a member of the
Libertarian Party. For example, Gary Johnson was a Republican governor of New
Mexico, but his policies were very libertarian. He didn’t become a Libertarian
until he ran for president in 2012.
Another reason that I’m writing libertarian with
a miniscule “l” is that I want to compare libertarians to liberals and conservatives,
not Libertarians to Democrats and Republicans.
We also need to define what a liberal is and what
a conservative is. A libertarian is fiscally responsible and socially tolerant.
A liberal is fiscally irresponsible and socially tolerant. A conservative is
fiscally responsible and socially intolerant. Although in recent years,
conservatives have become neo-conservatives. Neo-conservatives, or neo-cons,
are fiscally irresponsible and socially intolerant, the worst of both worlds.
We can also define libertarian with a quote from
Andre Marrou, the Libertarian candidate in 1992:
“Liberals want the government to be your Mommy.
Conservatives want government to be your Daddy. Libertarians want it to treat
you like an adult.”
I believe this quote sums up the differences among
liberals, conservatives, and libertarians perfectly. Conservatives want to
protect you from external enemies like your father would. Liberals want to
protect you from yourself like your mother would. Libertarians don’t want to be
your parents or your nanny.
Liberals & Conservatives & Libertarians, Oh My!
I believe that Matt Stone and Trey Parker have
influenced, whether it was their intention or not, a generation of young people
to be more libertarian with their show South
Park. They sum up their political beliefs with the following statement:
“I hate conservatives, but I really fucking hate
liberals.”
If this book works the way I intend, liberals and
conservatives who read it will be libertarians when they finish it. I will use
certain episodes as a point of departure to discuss certain issues. In some
cases, I will use my experience in France to drive the point further. I will
cite some prominent libertarians, but in many cases I don’t cite anything. As
you read, you will notice that I spend more time trying to convince liberals to
be fiscally responsible than I do trying to convince conservatives of being
socially intolerant. That is because I believe that fiscal responsibility can
be taught more easily than social tolerance. Social intolerance is often
motivated by deep religious beliefs, and it is virtually impossible to change
one’s religious beliefs.
For example, Rick Santorum is very conservative,
and I don’t think anyone can convince him to be socially tolerant. In fact,
Santorum recently said that the Republicans are losing elections because
they’re not anti-gay enough. I’m more optimistic of influencing those who don’t
feel very strongly about the liberal-conservative dichotomy.
My job in France gave me so much time off that I
was able to contemplate the role of government in our lives. And I was able to
come to many conclusions, which I discuss in this book, without having read
anything about libertarianism beforehand. I used to be liberal, but then I
realized that I was a libertarian all along. I just didn’t know it.
Each chapter from Chapter Two to Chapter Sixteen
is named after an episode from South Park.
The chapters begin with a description of the episode, in case you haven’t seen
it. If you’re an avid South Park fan,
you won’t need to read these of course. Some descriptions are longer or shorter
than others. The subsequent subsections contain a libertarian lesson from that
episode. The episode is used as a point of departure, and there are a few
subsections that don’t pertain directly to the episode, but rather to the
lesson in it. You will notice that a few chapters have more lessons than
others. For example, Chapter Two contains many lessons discussed that could
easily be discussed in other episodes. While many of the libertarian lessons of
South Park are often repeated in
multiple episodes, each lesson will be discussed only once, but they may be
mentioned a few more times.